Does anyone know where the "list of trees" is published for the tree ring data used in the analysis for the upcoming paper. I have played around with some of the controversial stuff (for instance, tree YAD061 and other "Yamal trees"), but so far, I haven't found a reliable source that lists the trees they kept and those they ditched when they generated the series.

I have the same question about the borehole temperature data and whatever else they used.

Edit (01/20/2011) ==============================

Here's a better description of what I'm looking for.

I realize that what is about to be discussed is the analysis/processing of the "incoming data". However, a second issue is the "incoming data" itself, and can I (a mere mortal) duplicate what the authors have done?

Here's an example:

First, something part of, or similar to the "incoming data":


Figure A shows their "hockey stick". Then there's a description of the "Regional Curve Standardisation", then a map showing the location of the trees, and believe it or not, an actual description of the raw data that was used. The data sets are at:


Such that if you want to fool with the data for a specific tree, you can. For example, I can download and play with tree YAD061 (from 1803 to 1996):


My goal is to understand what the authors did so I can get an idea of how reasonable the "incoming data" really is.

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks for moving the question to meta. I've just deleted your original question from the main site. $\endgroup$ Jan 19, 2011 at 22:05


You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .