The thread Policy on R questions: Stackoverflow vs Stats Analysis suggests that we have some difference of opinions as to how to approach this issue. To get to some sort of resolution I propose that we use this thread to offer several different proposals and let the votes decide what we should do. I would suggest that we follow the following ground rules:
The suggested policy measures are mutually exclusive. So, please vote up the one policy that you think we should adopt.
Do not downvote any proposal. I suggest that we do not count downvotes at the end of the polling period to decide what to do.
If you wish to add another policy proposal feel free to do so with the caveat that your proposal must be distinct from the ones already existing.
Let us run the poll for one week i.e., till Nov 5th, 2010. The proposal with the highest number of upvotes will be the proposal we will adopt as far as R questions are concerned.